When you experience infertility, it seems that every other woman in the world is pregnant. I still have that feeling, but not just in that concrete obvious way. I often get the impression that every thing, every comment, is geared to draw attention to my infertility and conspire to make me feel inadequate and a failure.
A less-than woman. A less-than person.
This has happened twice this week, two experiences that really stayed with me and left me chewing over them during my drive into work today.
The first happened at the museum of fine art over the weekend. My mother and I had gone to spend a day out together, and I was happily reading the little notes to the left of the paintings, when I read a description that I allowed to steal my joy away. It read,
Famous Artist So-and-so considered motherhood to be the ideal expression of womanhood.
And then I read this article on CNN.com and the kicker phrase in this article states:
Having a baby is the ultimate bonding experience.
Comments like these only serve to accomplish one thing in my life: they make me feel that my experiences are condemned to be less than ideal, that no matter what I do, I can never have a full life, and that I can never fulfill the requirements of ideal womanhood. They scream to me that I should just get used to the idea that I will never know ultimate bonding, that no matter how hard I try, I will never measure up to even the minimum standard.
I was turning these thoughts over in my head this morning, trying to reconcile them with my heart, when I heard the Holy Spirit say to me, clear as day, “Trish, that’s the world talking. You know that’s not true for you.”
Wow. Just let that sink in for a minute, because even as I write this, I have to pause and let my thoughts catch up with my beating heart.
It is the world’s view, and it’s so insidious that it can influence even our best-intentioned Christian thoughts. What makes it so seductive is how pure it seems on the surface. Afterall, the world asks, what can be more pure than motherhood? What can be more perfect than the bond between a woman and her children?
It’s an illusion, a distraction, from the truth. It’s Satan’s subtle way of saying, It’s a beautiful feeling, so it must be right. By focusing our views and thoughts on childbearing as the ultimate and ideal , the true Ultimate and Ideal is overshadowed in our minds: God.
It places childbearing on an untenable pedestal, makes it the new idol, the new theology of our society. Even our values are now phrased in terms of Family Values, not God’s Values.
Christian women also fall victim to this seductive view of womanhood. I know I have. And I’ve had kind and sincere well-meaning Christian friends say they are praying for me that I would have children, “because you can’t really understand and experience God’s love until you’ve had children of your own.”
Talk about killing me with kindness! According to this viewpoint, not only can I never attain the ultimate and ideal expressions of womanhood, I also will never fully experience God’s love!
But Sisters, it’s a lie that motherhood is the highest calling of women. It’s a warm, beautiful, and seductive lie, and to those of us who are precluded from it’s fulfillment, it’s a sharp and bitter sword that separates us from finding our true worth and purpose as women of God.
I have to remind myself, when the world tells me that I’m less than the ideal expression of womanhood, that God tells me that the ideal expression of my womanhood, the reason He created me, was to worship Him. That the ideal expression of my personhood, above all, is to be Christ’s ambassador on this earth, to be like Christ.
To understand God’s love through the love of a child is a step in the right direction, and I don’t mean to take anything away from parents in this regard! It’s a beautiful bond that cannot be imitated. If you are a parent, please don’t take offense, but your love of your children, while strong and undeniable, is not the ultimate love.
Jesus said, If you love those who love you, what reward will you get? Are not even the tax collectors doing that? And if you greet only your brothers, what are you doing more than others? Do not even pagans do that? Be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect. (Matthew 5:46-48)
I believe that in this passage, Jesus is saying, “It’s perfectly natural to love your children and your family, it’s the way you are designed. But the true measure of your love is how you love those who are unlovely, who are not your flesh and blood, who are unloved.”
Perfect love, as God loves, is to love super-naturally. Beyond the natural. That’s how God demonstrates His love. Certainly, a mother can aspire do that.
But so can a woman with no children!
As women, we need to be careful about not letting the world set our standards. As Christian women, we need to be especially careful of this, because while it is good to study and reflect on the qualities of faithful mothers and women in the Bible as models of earthly women who walked in faith and love, they are models for living, but should not be our ideal models for living.
Our only ideal should be Christ, and the ultimate bonding experience that we seek should be the bond of relationship between our soul and God.
So while I may indeed be missing out on the experiences of motherhood, while I may indeed never fulfill the world’s view of perfect womanhood, I need not fear missing out on the Ideal or the Ultimate on account of my disease or my inability to bear children.
God is my Ideal and my Ultimate.

15 comments
Comments feed for this article
January 30, 2008 at 12:45 pm
screamofcontinuousness
wow.
I seem to say that a lot after reading your work. Wow.
Way to turn the issue on it’s head and force me to see it differently. I had never once thought about the “ideal of motherhood” as being a possible idol that had crept into a higher place than God.
January 30, 2008 at 1:43 pm
andrea_jennine
So true. I’ve been thinking about similar things lately, about how the world and even the culture of the church seems in many ways to say that motherhood is the ultimate expression of femininity. But that’s just not true. An expression of femininity, sure. But the expression? No. Look at that great biblical example of womanhood in Proverbs 31. By no means is her character defined by her relationship to her children. She is a composite of many roles.
January 30, 2008 at 3:15 pm
marina lombardo
Trish, I could not agree more with your criticism of being a traditional mother as the sole and ultiimate bonding experience for women. In fact, I believe that mothering and the act of bonding is so natural for many women, that the best “mothers” i have known have often not had children at all.
I write the column “Emotionally Speaking” for Conceive Magazine, and back a couple of years ago, they asked me to write a column for mother’s day. I entitled the column, “Celebrating the Mother In Us All,” and in the column I quoted Adrienne Rich in her book, “Woman Born: Motherhood as Experience and Institution.” Her words are so beautiful, that I’d like to share them with you:
“The ‘childless woman’ and the “mother’ are a false polarity…There are no such simple categories…(once) all females, of whatever age, were called ‘mothers’–even little girls. Women…were sisters to one another and mothers to all children of the community without regard to which individual mother bore any child.”
Mothering is not just what women do…it is who we are.
Many blessings
marina lombardo
http://www.iammorethanmyinfertility.wordpress.com
info@iammore.net
January 30, 2008 at 5:59 pm
Lori
Yes, yes. I have seen women get so consumed by the power of motherhood that they decide they no longer need their husbands. It was frightening and sad to say the least.
We cannot forget that all things are gifts from God. He creates, we do not. He choses to bless us with our abilities and circumstances.
I like these verses from 1 Corinthians:
“Christ made us right wtih God; he made us pure and holy, and he freed us from sin. Therefore, as the Scriptures say, ‘If you want to boast, boast only about the Lord.’” (30b-31)
This is the ideal, and so many miss it.
January 30, 2008 at 9:58 pm
Christina
Thank you for writing this eye opening post. I really needed to see that. Please don’t stop writing.
January 30, 2008 at 10:22 pm
Steph
Thank you for your comments. I find myself falling prey to the world’s view of being a mother. I appreciated your reference to Matthew 5. Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I needed to hear them.
January 31, 2008 at 10:06 am
Janna
Thank you so much for writing this. I SOOOO needed to hear this message. Many days I feel like nothing because I don’t have children. And on those days I’m coming to reread this post. You have an amazing gift of lifting other up. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!!!
February 1, 2008 at 2:39 pm
Jennifer
Great words, Trish! I always love to read what you have to say!
PS: I tagged you for a round robin get-to-know-you!
February 7, 2008 at 5:08 pm
Missy
Amen sister.
This same lie is what causes so many mothers to idolize the children they do have.
We are created to bring God glory. Period. The ways that God provides us to live out that calling are as unlimited and as fascinating as the stars in the sky.
February 11, 2008 at 12:04 pm
Jon
Even as a Christian of the non-female variety – AMEN!
We can all really learn from this
Jon
http://faithfertility.blogspot.com/
February 20, 2008 at 11:21 am
Excellent Post « Life Capture
[...] over at blessed are the barren. check it [...]
March 31, 2008 at 6:39 am
Jess
Thank you so much for your words. God led me here to your blog today because I needed to read that. I want to read more – and I will – but I have to let this post sink in first. You’ve blessed me tremendously today. Thank you.
January 20, 2009 at 11:46 pm
bonnie
I found your blog today, and I wanted to say thanks for your writings.
It is so encouraging to hear from a mature Christian woman, faithfully following God along the path of infertility and childlessness. I’m taking my first steps along that path as my husband and I begin treatment, and the few posts I’ve read on your blog have encouraged me and rebuked me. They were just what I needed to hear.
August 17, 2009 at 8:00 am
what to say « stream of continuousness
[...] do yourself a huge favor. Read this blog post from a friend of mine. It address some theological and cultural hurdles that infertile women face in the church. It [...]
September 6, 2009 at 1:03 pm
Deziree
You have put into words what I was feeling. Thank you so much.